Thursday, August 8, 2013

In Memoriam

This is - sorry, was - Inisfada, completed in 1918 for a railroad and tobacco magnate named Nicholas Brady (1878-1930). Brady and his brother James were rich New York businessmen, neither of whom was particularly "social." For one thing, they were Catholic, a big blot on your social copy book back then. The Bradys bought 300 acres of bucolic woods and fields outside Manhassett (in an area amusingly called the Irish Channel), hired a curiously obscure architect to design a country cottage, and named it in-ish-FAH-dah, meaning "Long Island" in Gaelic. Brady died in 1930 and in 1937, after less than 20 years, his widow gavs Inisfada to the New York Province of the Society of Jesuits. After a seventy-five-year tax holiday the Jesuits unloaded St. Ignatius Retreat House, as they had come to call it, on a Hong Kong real estate developer for a cool $36 million. Did the Jesuits make any serious effort to preserve the greatest architectural icon in the town they'd called home for 3/4 of a century? That would be a no. The developer's initial goal was to demolish the Brady house, which he accomplished with the invaluable assistance of a town board so tone deaf to the cries of the community and simultaneously wedded to the idea of "progress" as "destruction of the old." Here's what it looked like as a retreat house.

December-January, 2014-2015

Did the Jesuits love Inisfada? Yes. But no, they didn't mmke any serious attempt to safeguard its future. They, or those to whom they answered, felt no responsibility to the community that had hosted them for 75 years. At least, not one that I could see.

While not exactly an insult, the "Irish Channel" wasn't precisely a compliment either. During the politically incorrect 1920s, it was a smug WASP joke referring to an imprecisely bounded section of Long Island's North Shore favored by rich Irishmen. Most Americans today have forgot that back in 1960 the election of Irish-Catholic John Kennedy occasioned no less national amazement than the election of African-American Barack Obama.

The Irish business barons of the late 19th and early 20th centuries tended to fall into three groups, vis a vis Catholicism and American "society." According to the old saw, heaven was a palace with many doors, but a gentleman used the one marked "Episcopalian." Ergo, the first group either abandoned Catholicism altogether and/or raised their children in whatever fashionable Protestant church was handiest. The second group may or may not have been good Catholics, but didn't care about society so it didn't matter what they did. The third group embraced Catholicism with a special zeal, sometimes showering Catholic charities with sufficient millions to attract the attention of the pope himself. Nicholas Brady and his wife Genevieve fell into the third category.

The original estate covered 300-or-so acres on Searingtown Road between Northern Blvd and the Long Island Espressway. The aerial view above, taken some time in the 1920s, looks south over rural Manhasset. Searingtown Road runs diagonally from mid-left to upper right. Inisfada's main drive is the tree lined allee that starts at Searingtown on the left and disappears out of sight on the right. The drive, which originally afforded fine views of the house, is now buried within a condo complex called Estates I. The entrance to St. Ignatious Retreat House was moved slightly north on Searingtown Road. On the eve of the recent sale to developmers, Inisfada's original 300-acre estate had been reduced to a 33-acre island surrounded by a sea of condos, superhighways and subdivision houses.

When the Bradys started buying land in Manhasset, they were in their 30s, married ten years, childless but presumably hoping. Their architect was a man I've never heard of, John T. Windrim (1866-1934) of Philadelphia, PA. Windrim's practice focused on banks, office buildings, telephone exchanges, police stations, hospitals, and the like. He was the designer of the famous Franklin Institute on Logan Square in Philadelphia. Of course, Inisfada is the size of many a not-so-small institutional building - its in-house telephone system had 89 extensions - so maybe the architect was less of an odd choice than one might think.

Inisfada was gorgeously detailed with stone and wood carving, and was pervasively religious even before the Jesuits arrived. The medallion above the porte cochere, for instance, depicts Mrs. Brady's namesake, St. Genevieve. For those who may have forgot, she is the patron saint of Paris, credited with saving that city from the depredations of Atilla the Hun, purely through the power of prayer.

Here's Nicholas Brady in a photo taken, judging from his collar, around the time Inisfada was either under construction or recently finished. Brady's father, Anthony, was a classic American success story - a penniless Irish immigrant who rose to economic prominence by his own smarts. The elder Brady was, among many other things, president of the New York Edison Company. He was also one of those Irishmen who cast aside Catholicism and raised his children in the Anglo-Saxon faith of Ireland's historic oppressors. His eldest son Nicholas, interestingly, converted to Catholicism in 1905, the year before his marriage to another child of the Catholic elite, the devout Genevieve Garvan. It's tempting to suspect a man with so much privilege - and such a big house! - as being irredeemably self-satisfied. However, this same man once said, "What are rich people but the trustees of God for the deserving poor and honest labor... The working man's right and dignity should come before high dividends." I hope he meant it.

Brady died unexpectedly in New York in March of 1930 at the age of 52. Of the financial empire over which he and his brother, James Cox Brady, presided, the press observed, "A New Yorker cannot light his gas or turn on his electric bulb without adding to their riches." Those riches were augmented by major holdings in mining, banking, fuel, iron, sugar and rubber. Plus which, according to the press of the day, you could, "hardly puff a cigarette or enjoy your favorite pipe without paying tribute to the Bradys." More about that in a moment. In 1926, in the wake of a million dollar gift to the Vatican, Pope Pius XI made Brady and his wife a papal duke and duchess. After his death, Brady's widow, seen below receiving an honorary Doctor of Laws degree from Georgetown University, continued their Catholic philanthropies with, if possible, even more of an open hand.

This man is Francis Garvan, Nicholas Brady's college roommate and Genevieve Brady's brother. Garvan was another Catholic swell from the Irish Channel who happened to be married to Brady's sister, Mabel. In late 1923 he represented his wife and another Brady sister in a nasty lawsuit alleging that Nicholas and James Brady had misappropriated funds - specifically relating to tobacco stock - from a Brady family trust. The Brady boys had, in truth, been using the trust as a sort of personal private bank. The case made juicy headlines in late 1923 and early 1924. A lead in the Times on January 10, 1924, reads, "Witness and Lawyer Appeal to Court to Stop Each from Insulting the Other." The case, settled out of court, once again leaves unresolved the old question of how much money is enough.

To circumnavigate Inisfada on foot was to realize how immense it was. Oheka, the late Otto Kahn's estate in Cold Spring is generally held to be the largest house on Long Island, but I don't see how it could really be bigger than this. Inisfada's porte cochere is obscured by the big tree.

The terrace adjoined an enormous solarium located at the western end of the house. An elaborate master bedroom suite on the 2nd floor was one of the very few parts of Inisfada's remarkably preserved interior to be destroyed during conversion to institutional use.

The view from the terrace originally looked down an axis of formal gardens, now mostly lawn. The vintage view in the second image below looks the other direction towards the house. The formal pool with its lovely statue was apparently a later addition.

My guide, St. Ignatius Administrator Tom Evrard, is standing in front of the south facade. There were originally sweeping views from here down to the drive, and beyond that to distant open fields and woody hills. The solarium is out of sight on the left. The big windows in the middle right are located in a great hall whose organ pipes are housed at the top of the stone tower.

The weeping beech in the middle of today's view is pretty spectacular, but the distant prospect is gone and condos are now tucked behind the trees.

Every big old house makes me wonder what it would be like to live there, regardless of size. I may have met my match with Inisfada.

Enough dreaming. Let's cut across the kitchen court, circle the end of the east wing and head for the front door.

Inside the front door was a stone entry hall which adjoined a (gulp) 163-foot long hallway. This hallway traversed the spine of the main body of the house. The solarium was at its western end; the dining room at the east. Typical coat rooms flanked either side of the entrance hall. I took a peek at one before moving along.

Now we're in the middle of the hallway looking west towards the solarium. The front door is to our right; the second image is a detail of the carving above the first arch in the distance.

The heart of Inisfada is the great hall, seen below in its salad days. The widow Brady's grandest hour arguably came in the fall of 1936 when Vatican Secretary of State, Cardinal Eugenio Pacelli, visited the United States and stayed at Inisfada...for a month. According to the Times, the visiting cardinal "appeared greatly impressed by the magnitude of the structure." Mrs. Brady, who had been received by the pope in 1935, was by this time considered the preeminent Catholic woman in America. Before the cardinal left, she gave a dinner in his honor for 700 guests. It was Inisfada's last great party. In March of 1939, Cardinal Pacelli became Pope Pius XII.

Here are Mrs. Brady and the cardinal in the great hall at Inisfada during his 1936 visit.

The door in the image below connects the west end of the great hall to an elegant adjoining salon. Inisfada was filled with so much bravura craftsmanship that it was easy, even in the last pre-demolition years, not to notice that a lot of it was missing. The simple surround and painted brick on the fireplace in the second image below would never have passed muster in the Brady days. That's because the original marble mantelpiece was sold at auction. Not long after Cardinal Pacelli's visit, Mrs. Brady moved to Rome and donated her mansion on 122 of its original 300 acres to the Jesuits. In February of 1937, 11,500 curious gawkers filed through Inisfada, at 50 cents a head, to see how the one percent of the one percent lived. That May, a famous 6-day auction of Inisfada's contents raised almost $450,000 for charity. The highest price paid for any single item was $900, on May 13th, for a Georgian claw-and-ball-foot concertina table. A man named E. Holt bought the dining room paneling for $3500. The wine in the cellar was left for the Jesuits.

Here's the salon as it looked before the auction.

The door to the salon is on the right; the dining room is in the distance at the eastern end of the hallway; the front door and entrance hall is to the left of the chandelier. Behind us is the main stair.

Opposite the main stair was another salon, rather obviously simplified for use as a meeting room. Hanging on its walls were an evocative set of framed photos showing Inisfada's interiors with original furniture.

Down a short hall just west of the main stair were the solarium, a library and the original billiard room.

We're back in the hallway facing east. The front door was to the left; the great hall behind the wall on the right; the dining room dead ahead. A secondary main staircase, located at the east end of the hallway and a tick or two less grand than the first, is out of sight to the left of the dining room.

This was originally the breakfast room, located next to the dining room and across from the eastern main stair. The door in the third image below originally opened into the great hall. It was blocked at the time of my visit by the altar on the other side.

The vintage image of the dining room shows the late 17th Century pine paneling that went for $3500 in 1937.

Far more interesting than the cannibalized dining room were Inisfada's extensive - and virtually intact - pantry and kitchen suites.

When I stepped inside Inisfada for the first time, I wanted to use the front door. By the same token, when Tom and I went upstairs I wanted to take the main stair. This required a considerable hike back from the servant hall in the image above.

The elevator clanks up and down with a good deal of wheezing but appears to be dependable.

The master bedroom seen in the vintage image below was part of a luxurious suite located at the top of the main stairs and directly over the solarium. This suite was not just chopped up, but finely diced into fourteen cells for Jesuit seminarians. The ceiling beams, visible in the second image below, were all that survived.

We're looking east on the second floor from the top of the main stair. The master bedroom suite is behind us; guestrooms are ahead on the left; the upper portion of the great hall is behind the wall on the right; the door at the end of the hall leads to a sort of high-value guest suite. Cardinal Pacelli stayed there during his visit in 1936. To the right of the suite is the not famous enough private chapel dedicated to St. Genevieve; to the left is the second main stair.

This door leads to a musicians' gallery that overlooks the great hall. The original organ pipes are two flights up inside a stone tower on top of the house.

The guestrooms, as expected, were lovely, even though numerous fireplace mantels had gone missing and the once grand bathrooms "updated" in ersatz fashion.

I love mail slots in guestroom doors. How delicious to think of being a guest in Manhasset for long enough to have your mail delivered there.

Here's the east main stair, and across from it...

...the door to the private chapel.

I have seen a few private chapels, and this one was hard to beat. It was salvaged during demolition for installation at Fordham University in the Bronx.

The first view below shows the lobby of the high-value guest suite. It's got two rooms and a formerly sumptuous bath that had been converted into a dispirited looking kitchen. The second image looks west from the lobby to the master suite in the distance.

Another second floor hall, this one located above the kitchen and pantries, leads to more guestrooms, and ends finally in a servants' stair at the eastern end of the house.

The "not-for-the-servants" main stair on the east leads, unexpectedly, to a multitude of servants' rooms distributed along very very long third floor corridors. I like the ceiling motifs at the top of this stair, although I cannot figure out what's chasing the rabbit.

Inisfada is so big that it wasn't until I got home and looked at my photos that I realized I'd forgot to go to the top of the tower. Tom Evrard understood completely, invited me back, even picked me up at the station in Manhasset. Climbing the stone stairs to the highest point on Inisfada was a voyage of discovery - of organ pipes, multiple chimneys, and a panorama of former farmland whose modern tree-shaded subdivisions, from this height anyway, look like virgin forestland. Now even that tower is gone.

From the roof, we went straight to the basement for my obligatory look at the boilers. In 2013 those twin behemoths, each hiding beneath a sort of giant tea cosy, burned 80,000 gallons of oil.

We exited the house via the kitchen court and walked around to the front.

Genevieve Brady's childlessness is said to have instilled in her a particular love for children. This may or may not have been true, but it is supposed to explain the unexpected presence of whimsical stone medallions on the facade depicting nursery rhyme and fairy tale characters. Little Red Riding Hood was easy to identify.

There was an odd one in the gable above the master bedroom, identified by one source as Mother Hubbard. To me it looks like a scene from Hansel and Gretel. The same year that Mrs. Brady donated Inisfada to the church, she married William J. Babbington Macauley, the Irish Free State's Minister to the Holy See. One year later, in 1938, at the age of 53, she died in Rome as suddenly and unexpectedly as her first husband. A thousand people attended her memorial at St. Ignatius Loyola on Park and 84th. She was buried, curiously, alongside that first husband at a Pennsylvania novitiate he had endowed before his death.

My guides, Tom Evrard and Kathy Waldow, were the souls of hospitality and helpfulness during two visits to Inisfada. In fact, everybody there couldn't have been nicer.

After 75 years, first as a Jesuit school, then a seminary and finally a retreat house, St. Ignatius closed in 2013. The decision was economic one and it saddened everybody, especially the surrounding community in which many saw the Jesuits as stewards of a local cultural artifact. This was not the mindset of church officials, however, who were focussed from the beginning on getting the most dollars possible for the property, with little or no concern for possible impact on the community. And so it's gone, a wonderful house worthy of another last look...and a sad shake of the head.


  1. Wow! This house is anything but cozy! Really, the sheer scale of these houses is staggering.
    Thank you again for your indefatigable exploring and reporting on another landmark.

    This one seems destined for a sad ending. Can't imagine too many good uses for this place...with the location (hemmed in by residential development) it's not really suited for conversion to an hotel. Maybe a conference center? Or some really clever (and expensive) conversion to condominiums within the historic structure itself?

  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  3. I hope maybe the county can step in in some way to help preserve this house and what's left of the property? Is there a cultural organization/or a few, that can relocate here? If this place is dismantled, destroyed, it'd be a huge loss.

  4. Thanks, John, for another great posting. I enjoyed every bit of it until I got to the last paragraph. When they "close" an old house of this size, it never seems to turn out very well. I'm hopeful that Mrs. Brady is looking down from Heaven...and maybe she'll cash in some of her chits to keep her beautiful old home from ruination.

    My Irish-American grandmother, who grew up in the early 1900s, had a saying about Irish people in America who make a lot of money. I forget how it was worded exactly, but she felt the richer they got, the more "Irish" they became.

  5. The church has been an incredible steward and protector of this amazing property. One can only pray that they ensure that whoever buys it is obligated to preserve this beautiful mansion. IT is big, but it is also wonderfully designed with so many unique architectural touches and moments of whimsy and joy. This place must be protected from the developers. I like Anon's 8:15 comment and I hope that the Brady's good deeds in life do serve to guide the Jesuits and help them find the right buyer for their home.

  6. My God, I love your blog so so so so so so so so so much. There, I have no fancy way of saying it! I get so excited when I see a new post! Thank you for the great work you do! Always a pleasure reading your blog! A greek fan!

  7. The three fish are a symbol of the Trinity. Not sure why, exactly, as the only mention of three fishes is in the story of the Feeding of the Five Thousand, but there you are.

  8. Great post. Just found this blog and love it!

  9. Will there be a service on Christmas Day?

  10. This post was interesting as well as the photos. I had a great time reading your work and for me this was informative. Thank you for sharing.

    You can also click herea

  11. My friend suggested me to visit your blog. Very well explained. Thanks for the write up! This is really some great stuff here! I will visit here very often.

  12. thanks for the information. We are putting togeather a group to try and save this wonderful part of Long Island History.

  13. This beautiful historic home which was a GIFT to the Jesuits is now sold and slated to meet it's fate by way of a wrecking ball. This historic icon should have been protected, respected and treasured. Shame on the Village of North Hills! Google Inisfada and read the latest updates - also NY Times article 7/31/13 Sec A

  14. There was a story about saving this property in the NYT that prompted me to come back and read this post again. I wish I had $45 million to save it let alone enough money to maintain it.

  15. This is a very sad story. The Jesuits share in 50% of the blame for literally shafting the Long Island communities that hosted them for generations. It is disrespectful and greedy to close up and not care what happens to the community and the people that you once served, let alone the magnificent building you once called home. They also provided a nice big old slap in the face to Mrs Brady's generosity too. Also the Village of North Hills will share the remaining 50% of the blame, run by a fool of a mayor who cant understand that this structure is an asset to his village and it's history. He has been quoted as saying he sees no historical importance in Inisfada and if the developers want to demolish it he will allow them to do so. The true meaning of village idiot is symbolized by the mayor of North Hills. The fact that we in the U.S. dont appreciate preserving our heritage, our culture, our environment and our past is disgraceful. Such structures will never be and can never be built again. You would think even fools like small minded village mayors would get the clue?

    1. So true, I live in the area. I drive by the St.Ignatitus Retreat House. Now I only see all the tree cut for more home. The area is over develop, and we lost part history of old architecture

  16. Beautiful place, grand as can be. But really, if the church received this incredibly valuable gift (and much else of great value) from the Bradys, then used it for a long long time, wouldn't one think that they should show some care at least to see that it's kept intact by whomever buys it, while they can keep all the free cash thus accrued. Surely such a stupendous place could fine some use besides food for the crusher.

  17. Kevin Orlin JohnsonAugust 11, 2013 at 4:13 AM

    Obviously, the Jesuits have kept the property, and kept it well, for as long as possible. Whatever else may be said of the order, they can't be accused of insensitivity to the arts!

    On little point, though. Pius XII was most certainly not silent on the treatment of the Jews. The Church co-ordinated efforts that saved hundreds of thousands, through fake baptismal certificates, diplomatic visas, and even opening Castelgandolfo and other residences as refuges, packed even in the corridors with cots for Jews seeking safety.

    Pius himself was untiring in his efforts to get the word out, but Churchill and Roosevelt ignored him. The pope then took out full-page ads in the New York Times detailing the atrocities--they're still there in the paper's archives, and they're still ignored, as the whole history of the episode is ignored, by American historians--who show a persistent prejudice against the Church. But the documents are there for anybody to see.

    Thanks for so many great shots of this very interesting building!

  18. Could we keep the focus on efforts to ensure the survival of this house and not on blaming this or that party for its peril, or on historical sidebars? Why, for instance, as has been done many times before, can't Inisfada be turned into residences? There are dozens of successful examples in the US and particularly in the UK, where instead of dividing such enormous houses into flats floor-by-floor, resulting in a lot of chopping up of the large downstairs rooms, a vertical division has frequently been employed. I brought this up on the Old Long Island blog and only hope somebody was listening, or is listening now, who has connections in the real estate development world. That the house COULD be preserved in a way that would allow the current owners a reasonable return on their investment SHOULD be possible. Finger-pointing isn't where Inisfada's would-be protectors should be directing their energies. Defeatism likewise will not lead to a good outcome. Persuasion, in the form of a well-placed, diplomatically expressed word or two in the right quarter, still might.

  19. That hall, by the way, appears to be even bigger than the one at Hatfield House, among the largest of the Prodigy Houses of the Elizabethan-Jacobean era in England when owners often bankrupted themselves sacrificing at the altar of conspicuous consumption.

  20. It would be a shame to see it go. It would be nice to see the new owners find a good use for it. Condo's / lofts maybe .

  21. It seems a wrecking ball has been delivered to the site. Farewell, beautiful house.

  22. Demolition of Inisfada began December 5, 2013. And while it's shameful that the house was destroyed, your photos serve as an invaluable record of a singular and amazing building. Thank you for sharing them with your readers.

  23. I appreciate you keeping this site up and running. I walked the grounds during the demolition in December and took pictures of the exposed walls all around Inisfada. Bathroom stalls, drapes, wooden wall carvings and more lay exposed, waiting to be pulled down and carted away. The insensitive way the Jesuits disposed of this holy place, has broken the hearts of many hundreds of faithful Catholics.Your website helps keep the memories of a warm and inviting palace alive in our hearts.

  24. I went on many retreats at St. Ignatius Rrtreats..It was like leaving the world for 3 short nights..Father Damian presented mass on Sunday mornings..At one time they house a man from another country who was receiving many surgeries from burns and needed a place to live..We would often hear the sound of a piano coming from a downstairs room and it was beautiful.. I have wonderful memories there..I know they needed much work including a new boiler system that would cost 100,000 dollars, amongst many other repairs..I was also saddened when news came out regarding the coming closure..I attended Father Damiani last mass to a full house.. I am deeply grateful to have enjoyed this great house and will hold onto the wonderful memories..It is my understanding that Genevieve Chapel was dismantled and reset in Fordham University. I have since moved to Asheville North Carolina and on a return visit to New York I would love to see the Chapel..

  25. I went on many retreats at St. Ignatius Retreats..It was like leaving the world for 3 short nights..Father Damian presented mass on Sunday mornings..At one time they housed a man from another country who was receiving many surgeries from burns and needed a place to live..We would often hear the sound of a piano coming from a downstairs room and it was beautiful.. I have wonderful memories there..I know they needed much work including a new boiler system that would cost over 100,000 dollars, amongst many other repairs..I was also saddened when news came out regarding the coming closure..I attended Father Damiani last mass to a full house.. I am deeply grateful to have enjoyed this retreat house and will hold onto the wonderful memories..It is my understanding that St.Genevieve Chapel was dismantled and reset in Fordham University. I have since moved to Asheville North Carolina and on a return visit to New York I would love to see the Chapel again.

  26. Professional movers usually assess the property before they start packing the truck and they make a plan in their minds as to how to tackle whatever items you need moved. Best Movers Near Me

  27. Memory foam mattresses are the most comfortable mattresses available in the market. freight broker